Technologyadmin on 11 Aug 2007 08:20 am
A wrote a few weeks ago about the security problems with social networking sites such as bebo and myspace. Today I watched a Panorama episode about children fighting and then this being uploaded to the web, in what is being called just another form of cyberbullying.

Once again this highlights the lack of education and parental responsibility of many parents these days. The images that where shown on the program were all too common a hearing in today’s schools. Pupils bragging to each other about what they have watched and uploaded to sites such as YouTube.
We have also heard in the news and media about individuals, often youngsters of teenage years being attacked and filmed using a mobile phone and then this being uploaded to YouTube for the [sick] world to watch. This is wrong and is getting out of hand quickly. Being a teacher you get to hear about more and more stories of this sort of thing happening with pupils. The question remain as to what can be done about it.
Many of the teaching unions have called for these websites to be banned, however I believe that once again this is just treating the symptoms and not the cause. It seems at the moment that unfortunately it is fashionable, cool and trendy for many [and I know not all!] young people to behave as bullies and in a violent and abusive way towards others. One of the ways in which this is done is through sites such as YouTube. Twelve months ago were heard incidents of so called ‘happy slapping” and at the time that wasn’t really dealt with by the law. It was passed off to be a minor problem that would phase itself out. How wrong they were as this minor problem has now grown to all out violent attacks in some cases.
For the situation to change it is time to go back to basics in teaching young people the basics of respect and manners. Unfortunately to many parents think that this is the job of teachers. How wrong can they be. Parents should pass along these qualities to their children so that when they reach school the work is already done. As the title describes, teachers teach what they were trained in, whether it was Geography or Maths or whatever subject, but they are never trained to teacher good manners and respect to kids, as that is the job of the parents.
Another step is the websites themselves. However unlike some of the teaching unions, shutting them down is not the answer. Bullying takes place in schools everyday (and probably in many workplaces) but we don’t shut them down. No, we change things in order to reduce the amount of bullying that happens. Well the same is needed for these websites.
Lets take YouTube as an example. At first you think anything can be posted on YouTube and you would be right. So how is policing of the content done. You may think that these website have a large team of people that check videos for inappropriate content. You would be wrong. The number of people that YouTube have checking the content uploaded to their site is zero. The reason is that they expect the users of the site themselves to police the content. This is done through flagging a video as inappropriate using a link below the video itself. YouTube then check the video (which can take a massive 48 hours) and then either remove it or leave it there is they think that it is OK. It was interesting to see what the Google (who own YouTube) spokes person had to say on the video regarding the policing of their site.

“If it is violent assault and if the police come to us and say they would like to prosecute someone because it was violent assault, we will cooperate with them if they’ve gone through the proper procedures.” (Rachel Whetstone, Google UK)
Surely it would make better sense to have the videos screened before they were uploaded. What Google are saying is that they want the police to do the work for them and therefore effectively they do not want to spend their profits policing their own site, they would rather have the tax payers money do it for them.
If people started putting up offensive posters outside the Google buildings, wherever they are, they would be onto the police to have them removed, they would not wait until a member of the public flagged it up with the police?
The policing of videos on sites like YouTube must change in the future. Videos that are uploaded must be policed in a better way than they are now. As I was suggesting in my last article if you knew who exactly was posting these videos then the content wouldn’t be as much as problem, because anything that is a criminal offence could be traced back to the user to press charges, whereas at the moment this cannot happen as you can post under any name you like. Since identity on these sites is unlikely to change the videos must therefore be screened before they go up on the web. Combine this with proper education and upbringing of children and the number of videos that are showing these graphic violent images would reduce by a lot, and maybe change the culture among many (not all) of today’s youth that this sort of behaviour is funny and acceptable.
–
[Video] Panorama - Children’s Fight Club (may expire)
Panorama Transcript - Children’s Fight Club
YouTube - Broadcast Yourself
BBC News - Cyberbullying